You could really use any cookie flavor or ice cream. The nice thing about the cookie is it makes an easy individual serving. I rolled one cookie up and stuffed it with Cherry Garcia Ice Cream. I also made a version with a flat cookie and Mocha Chocolate Chip Ice Cream (which, as a reader suggested, should be called the Baked Washington). It was tempting to try some sort of caramel ice cream but at the end I was too high on sugar, and frustrated by trying to photograph something that just keeps on melting, to dare try one more. So if any of you have any suggestions feel free to chime in.